Insurers Ordered to Compensate Despite Theft Claim Doubts

The policyholder filed a claim two days after her vehicle was reported stolen on March 23, 2022. She recounted purchasing the car from a friend, who is a certified motor mechanic, and leaving it at their house for servicing.

Insurance Manufacturers of Australia had raised numerous concerns about the circumstances surrounding the theft. These included a lack of proof of purchase and incomplete information about the vehicle's service history. The car was insured despite the new owner not driving it, which also raised suspicions. In addition, the friend did not cooperate with the insurer’s inquiries.

AFCA responded by stating that it is common for individuals to not have a purchase receipt when buying a vehicle privately. They accepted the bank statements showing a $35,000 transaction labeled "AA-Van" as adequate evidence of payment. They also acknowledged that service history details may have been in the vehicle at the time of theft.

The ruling emphasized that purchasing insurance was logical as it included coverage for non-driving events such as theft. While cooperation from the mechanic friend would have aided the investigation, it was not deemed a sufficient reason to reject the claim.

Concerns were also raised by the insurer about why the car remained with the friend for over nine months and inconsistencies in the car’s documented compliance and build dates. AFCA found no definitive reason for the extended storage but accepted explanations, such as Melbourne's lockdown and the complainant’s husband's health issues, as plausible.

The authority acknowledged a confusing situation regarding date inconsistencies but noted that the vehicle identification number (VIN) was consistent across documentation, thus confirming ownership and associated loss.

“Although it seems unlikely that a certified motor vehicle tester would make an error in the build date, it’s not an implausible mistake to make,” commented AFCA’s adjudicator.

Given all evidence, AFCA concluded that the complainant should be recognized as the owner who suffered a financial loss, and they instructed Insurance Manufacturers of Australia to accept the claim and process the payout.

For more details on the original case and ruling, refer to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority’s documentation.

Published:Monday, 29th Jul 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

APRA's Intervention: Freezing Unjustified Premium Hikes in Commercial Auto Insurance 06 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) has recently taken decisive action to address escalating concerns within the commercial auto insurance sector. In response to widespread industry protests over substantial premium increases, APRA has implemented emergency regulations aimed at protecting independent transport operators and logistics enterprises from potential financial distress. - read more

Navigating 2026: Key Challenges Identified by Australian Insurers 06 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori As 2026 unfolds, Australian insurers are confronting a trio of pressing challenges that are reshaping the industry's landscape. According to insights from Gallagher Bassett's upcoming report, 'The Carrier Perspective: 2026 Claims Insights,' the foremost concerns include rising premium costs coupled with shrinking insurability, escalating cyber and data risks, and increasing difficulties in attracting and retaining skilled workers. - read more

Addressing the Looming Truck Driver Shortage in Australia 06 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori Australia's transport industry is sounding the alarm over a significant and growing shortage of truck drivers, a situation that poses a substantial threat to the nation's supply chain. The National Road Transport Association (NatRoad) has highlighted that the current shortfall of approximately 28,000 drivers is projected to escalate to 78,000 unfilled positions by 2029, representing a 26% decrease from the current workforce of 189,900 drivers. - read more

APRA Emphasises Immediate Action on Extreme Weather Mitigation 06 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) has released a pivotal report highlighting the pressing need for immediate and substantial action to shield communities from the escalating impacts of extreme weather events. This Insurance Climate Vulnerability Assessment (ICVA) serves as a stress test, modelling potential future scenarios rather than forecasting specific outcomes. However, the risks outlined are already becoming evident, reinforcing the insurance industry's calls for urgent intervention to mitigate extreme weather risks. - read more