Quake Damage Claims Dismissed Over Previous Faults

The company behind the claim stated that the properties were impacted by a 5.4-magnitude earthquake that occurred in November 2018. Although the earthquake's epicenter was approximately 45 kilometers away from the buildings, Geoscience Australia specified the evident damage radius to be no more than 27 kilometers from the epicenter.

In their defense, the claimant's engineering expert conceded that the buildings were situated outside the primary damage zone but contended that the earthquake’s vibrations had unleashed energy beneath the geological formations on which the houses stood.

The expert identified "preexisting or dormant conditions" in the properties, including previously repaired damage which, according to him, reopened due to ground movement prompted by the quake, also leading to the manifestation of new fractures.

Meanwhile, Allianz, the insurance provider, enlisted a forensic civil and structural engineer who assessed the damages. His findings revealed brickwork fissures in multiple sections of one property, referred to as House H, and evident cracks within the garage of the second property, termed House P, in addition to a separation between a storeroom and the home.

The engineer hired by Allianz attributed the damage to prolonged foundation instability and deterioration of the mortar used in the brickwork, rather than to the seismic event.

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) upheld the insurer’s position, noting that both engineers corroborated the presence of damage similar to what was being contested even before the 2018 earthquake, specifically in House H.

AFCA further mentioned that updates made to certain rooms within the house remained unaffected, while external brickwork conditions pointed towards significant wear and tear, contributing to the losses. Comparable remarks were also made in regard to House P.

"While both experts agree it is conceivable for House H to incur earthquake-related damage under ideal conditions despite its location outside the designated impact radius, the insurer's expert refuted the existence of such conditions in this case," stated the adjudicator from AFCA.

"Even if the earthquake were recognized as being a proximate cause of the damage to House H, it would coexist with other excluded factors (wear and tear, prolonged structural movement)."

"Consequently, the insurer maintains the right to invoke those exclusions as a basis for denying the claim," AFCA concluded.

Published:Thursday, 1st Aug 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

HCF and Netball Australia Strengthen Commitment to Women's Health 19 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori HCF, Australia's largest not-for-profit health fund, has announced the extension of its major partnership with Netball Australia and Super Netball, continuing as the sport's official health insurance partner through to the end of 2027. This renewal underscores HCF's dedication to improving the health and wellbeing of Australian women by supporting netball at all levels—from grassroots participation to elite competition. - read more

Gold-Level Health Insurance Premiums to Surge by Up to 25% in 2026 19 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori Recent analysis by consumer advocacy group CHOICE has revealed that Australians holding gold-level health insurance policies may face premium increases of up to 25% starting in April 2026. This substantial hike significantly exceeds the average 4.41% increase approved by the government for private health insurance premiums. - read more

Instanda's AI Innovation: Transforming Commercial Underwriting 19 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori Instanda, a leading provider of insurance technology solutions, has unveiled an artificial intelligence (AI) system designed to revolutionize commercial underwriting. This innovative system addresses the longstanding challenge of balancing speed and accuracy in the underwriting process, a critical aspect for consultants seeking efficient and reliable insurance coverage. - read more

ICA's AI Initiative: Strengthening Fraud Detection in Insurance 19 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) has announced a collaboration with global AI leaders EXL and Shift Technology to develop a national data analytics fraud detection and investigations platform. This initiative aims to empower Australian insurers to unite in the fight against organized fraud networks, enhancing the integrity and reliability of the insurance industry. - read more