Horse Accident Claim Rejected: A Deeper Look into Trauma Insurance

The incident occurred on October 16 of the previous year, leading to a significant pelvic fracture for the claimant, followed by surgery a few days later. The woman has stated that her day-to-day activities have been severely affected as a result.

Currently, she is undergoing physiotherapy and taking medication to improve her mobility. Her orthopaedic surgeon, identified as Dr NJ, has reported that she exhibits "debilitating symptoms affecting her left leg and foot."

Despite these symptoms, Dr NJ remarked that it might take 18 to 24 months to see improvement, and confirmed that predicting a permanent condition is complex at this stage.

Clearview Life Assurance refused the claim, citing that their policy's "loss of independent existence" clause necessitates a permanent inability to perform at least two daily activities independently.

In June, the complainant's general physician noted that she requires crutches for mobility and is incapable of handling tasks such as shopping, laundry, food preparation, or housecleaning.

The claimant also stated she suffers from cognitive impairment and has not shown any nerve recovery since the incident. She contends it would be unreasonable to assume her condition will improve over time.

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) acknowledged the severity of her disability but indicated that the current medical advice suggests she could eventually recover.

"Dr NJ is in the best position to opine on the permanence of the disability, given his specialty and ongoing treatment of the complainant," AFCA noted. "He has said it's 'too early to declare a permanent condition' and has outlined the further testing and treatments that are in progress and planned."

Nonetheless, AFCA's decision leaves the door open for the claimant to present new medical evidence at a future point that might confirm the permanence of her disability.

"It may be possible for her to demonstrate with subsequent medical evidence that her disability is permanent," AFCA said. "However, based on the current evidence, I am not convinced her disability is permanent or irreversible."

This case offers a critical view into the complexities and challenges associated with trauma insurance claims and highlights the necessity for clear and definite medical proof in establishing the permanence of a condition.

Published:Tuesday, 1st Oct 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

NSW Productivity Commissioner Advocates for Immediate Ban on Strata Manager Commissions 22 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori In a significant development for New South Wales' housing sector, Productivity Commissioner Peter Achterstraat has called for the prompt elimination of commissions received by strata managers. This recommendation aims to bolster transparency and affordability within the state's burgeoning strata housing market. - read more

CHU's 2025 Strata Market Report: Stability in Strata Insurance Amid Rising House Insurance Costs 22 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori In its recently released 2025 State of the Strata Market report, CHU, Australia's leading strata insurance underwriting agency, provides an insightful analysis of the current landscape of strata insurance. The report underscores a notable stability in strata insurance premiums, which have seen a modest increase of 2.8% over the past year, rising from $954 to $981 per lot annually. This increment is significantly lower than the 14% surge observed in house insurance premiums during the same period. - read more

Insurance Council of Australia Advocates for Strata Law Reforms to Mitigate Rising Premiums in Victoria 22 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) has recently called for comprehensive reforms to Victoria's strata legislation, highlighting that inadequate governance and deferred maintenance are contributing to escalating insurance premiums for the state's strata property owners. This appeal underscores the pressing need for legislative updates to enhance the management and maintenance of strata-titled properties. - read more

Strengthening Small Business Resilience: ICA's Call for Insurance Reforms 22 Apr 2026: Paige Estritori In a recent submission to the Parliamentary Joint Committee's inquiry into small business insurance, the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) has highlighted the pressing need for reforms to enhance the resilience of Australia's 2.5 million small businesses. These enterprises, which employ nearly half of the private sector workforce, are facing mounting challenges due to escalating insurance premiums and evolving risks. - read more