Customer Wins in Insurance Dispute Over Laser Equipment

2

The crux of the dispute arose when the salon's laser machine broke down in February, and repair costs were estimated at $18,069. The salon owner had insured the machine for $50,000 in December of the previous year, following its second-hand purchase and refurbishment in 2012 for $66,000.

Despite acknowledging the damage, QBE Insurance reduced its compensation to $7,286, citing an underinsurance clause. QBE claimed that due to the model being discontinued, a replacement would necessitate insuring at $155,000.

The insurer's clause stipulated that if the sum insured was less than 80% of the "total new replacement value," the liability could be adjusted accordingly. However, the salon owner challenged this assessment, arguing that a comparable refurbished machine was valued between $30,000 and $45,000.

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) intervened, siding with the salon owner. AFCA declared that policy wording began ambiguous, noting discrepancies in terms such as "full value" and "total new replacement value", creating confusion about the clause's intent.

AFCA clarified: "When the policy is read as a whole, it indicates the laser should be insured for its full value, or what it would cost to replace with a similar laser in a similar condition." They refuted QBE's expectation that the salon owner should have insured the laser for $155,000, indicating she would never recoup more than $50,000 under policy terms.

This ruling mandates QBE to cover the repair costs, less the policy’s deductible. The case emphasizes the importance of clarity in insurance contracts and equitable treatment of claims.

Published:Wednesday, 27th Nov 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

AMA Advocates for Regulatory Reforms to Curb Health Insurers' Market Power 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori The Australian Medical Association (AMA) has recently highlighted concerns regarding the substantial market power wielded by private health insurers and its potential adverse effects on patient care and healthcare costs. In a position statement released on 4 February 2026, the AMA emphasised the need for regulatory reforms to prevent insurers from exploiting their dominant positions in the healthcare sector. - read more

Declining Value in Private Health Insurance: AMA Calls for Urgent Reforms 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori Recent findings from the Australian Medical Association (AMA) reveal a concerning trend in the private health insurance sector: Australians are facing higher premiums while experiencing diminishing returns on their policies. The AMA's latest Private Health Insurance Report Card, released on 5 December 2025, highlights the urgent need for reforms to address these issues. - read more

Private Health Insurers Under Fire for Premium Increases Despite Government Warnings 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori Private health insurers in Australia are facing mounting criticism for implementing significant premium increases, despite explicit warnings from the Health Minister. This development has sparked concerns about the affordability of healthcare and the practices employed by insurers to maximise profits. - read more

AIA Australia's Commitment to Mental Health: City2Surf Partnership 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori In August 2025, AIA Australia, a leading life, health, and wellbeing insurer, took a significant step in addressing the nation's mental health crisis by partnering with the City2Surf event in Sydney. This collaboration aimed to raise both funds and awareness for mental health, a pressing issue that has seen a notable increase in related insurance claims over recent years. - read more