Insurer Penalized for Mishandling Storm Damage Claim
Insurer Penalized for Mishandling Storm Damage Claim
The homeowner reported his damages following severe storms that hit in February 2022. The insurance company consulted a builder, referred to as PB, to evaluate the property damages.
PB's assessment claimed that the home had pre-existing damage and lacked waterproof integrity. Specific issues highlighted included clogged gutters, cracked and missing roof tiles, and an unconventional roofing method that permitted water intrusion.
According to PB, the storm did not directly damage the roof but worsened existing issues. This led Auto & General to deny the claim and revoke the policy in October 2022, accusing the homeowner of misrepresenting the property's condition as "good" when the policy began and during its renewal.
The homeowner contested the insurer’s stance, arguing that it was unjust. He presented a separate builder’s report, along with written statements and photographs, which demonstrated a lack of prior wall or ceiling damage.
The policyholder attributed the defects cited by PB to partial make-safe work, asserting that the gutters had been regularly maintained prior to the storm. He also mentioned the emergence of storm-induced mold in sections of his home.
While Auto & General did ultimately reverse its initial claim denial and arrange for a cash settlement the preceding October, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has decreed that the company must retract its claims of disclosure breach and issue a formal apology.
The AFCA identified “multiple erroneous assertions by PB alleging the complainant had neglected to maintain the property appropriately before the storm,” for which the homeowner provided contradicting proof.
The authority’s ombudsman commented, "I am satisfied the complainant reasonably believed that his home was in good condition and waterproof at the time of policy renewal in July 2021. Moreover, I think a reasonable person would agree with the complainant’s evaluation of his home's condition."
They further stated, "I conclude that the complainant did not misrepresent the property's state. Thus, the insurer made a mistake in deciding to cancel the policy."
The insurer has been directed to pay $2000 to cover non-financial losses due to its oversight in investigating the homeowner’s challenges to PB’s report, failure to acknowledge present mould, and incomplete make-safe actions.
The AFCA concluded that Auto & General should have sought a second, independent evaluation of PB’s findings. The resultant protracted claim process subjected the policyholder and his family to undue stress and anxiety.
The original source of this matter was reported by the Insurance News.
Published:Thursday, 23rd Jan 2025
Source: Paige Estritori
Share this news item:
| AMA Advocates for Regulatory Reforms to Curb Health Insurers' Market Power 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori The Australian Medical Association (AMA) has recently highlighted concerns regarding the substantial market power wielded by private health insurers and its potential adverse effects on patient care and healthcare costs. In a position statement released on 4 February 2026, the AMA emphasised the need for regulatory reforms to prevent insurers from exploiting their dominant positions in the healthcare sector. - read more |
| Declining Value in Private Health Insurance: AMA Calls for Urgent Reforms 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori Recent findings from the Australian Medical Association (AMA) reveal a concerning trend in the private health insurance sector: Australians are facing higher premiums while experiencing diminishing returns on their policies. The AMA's latest Private Health Insurance Report Card, released on 5 December 2025, highlights the urgent need for reforms to address these issues. - read more |
| Private Health Insurers Under Fire for Premium Increases Despite Government Warnings 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori Private health insurers in Australia are facing mounting criticism for implementing significant premium increases, despite explicit warnings from the Health Minister. This development has sparked concerns about the affordability of healthcare and the practices employed by insurers to maximise profits. - read more |
| AIA Australia's Commitment to Mental Health: City2Surf Partnership 14 Feb 2026: Paige Estritori In August 2025, AIA Australia, a leading life, health, and wellbeing insurer, took a significant step in addressing the nation's mental health crisis by partnering with the City2Surf event in Sydney. This collaboration aimed to raise both funds and awareness for mental health, a pressing issue that has seen a notable increase in related insurance claims over recent years. - read more |
| Understanding the Role of Life Insurance in Your Estate Plan Estate planning is a critical process that often goes overlooked, but it's essential for securing the financial future of your loved ones and ensuring your assets are distributed according to your wishes. It involves the careful organization and protection of an individual’s estate to minimize uncertainties and facilitate the smooth transfer of assets after their passing. While it may seem complex, understanding the basics of estate planning is necessary for every Australian adult, regardless of wealth. - read more
|
| Why Income Protection Insurance is Vital for Your Financial Security Income protection insurance is a type of coverage that provides you with a financial safety net in case you are unable to work due to illness or injury. It typically pays up to 75% of your regular salary, helping you to continue meeting your financial obligations during difficult times. - read more
|
| Income Protection Insurance and Tax Benefits: What You Should Know Income protection insurance is a type of cover designed to provide you with a safety net if you are unable to work due to illness or injury. By offering regular payments that replace a portion of your income, it helps ensure that you can maintain your lifestyle and cover essential expenses during challenging times. - read more
|
| Income Insurance: The Safety Net for Your Financial Goals in Australia Financial security is pivotal for anyone striving to meet their life goals, be it owning a home, educating children, or ensuring a comfortable retirement. In Australia, where uncertainties can disrupt our best laid-out financial plans, having a safety net in place is essential. Income insurance offers just that—protection against the unforeseen events that could impact your income earning abilities. - read more
|
A specific risk or cause of loss covered by an insurance policy, such as fire, theft, or flood.