Consumer Advocacy Calls for $250 Million Annual Insurer Contribution Fund

Tyrone Shandiman, Chair of ACIL, suggests that distributing the $250 million expense across all members of the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) would have minimal financial impact on individual insurers. He asserts that insurers have an obligation to redirect a portion of their substantial profits back to policyholders, rather than focusing solely on shareholder returns. According to Shandiman, the industry should actively participate in solutions rather than relying on government intervention alone.

The proposed funds would be allocated to support mitigation efforts in high-risk regions, offer premium relief for vulnerable consumers, create a research foundation to investigate long-term insurance affordability and availability strategies, and pilot programs that could justify significant government investment. ACIL emphasizes that insurers need to financially support these initiatives if they genuinely endorse mitigation and resilience measures.

Shandiman stresses that establishing such a fund would be a crucial step in rebuilding public trust in the insurance sector. He notes that insurers tend to propose solutions that do not require them to provide financial contributions, casting doubt on their commitment to true reform. This reluctance is juxtaposed with their record profit levels, while consumers in high-risk areas continue to face challenges in securing affordable insurance coverage.

The ACIL initiative suggests that the proposed funding could also be used to test and model strategies in support of the ICA's previously proposed $30 billion flood defense program. This program, outlined by ICA last month, calls for governmental investment over the next decade to alleviate growing concerns surrounding home insurance affordability.

The Insurance Council of Australia has acknowledged Mr. Shandiman's proposal but has not publicly committed to the initiative.

Published:Tuesday, 18th Mar 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Cafe's Underinsurance Leads to Reduced Storm Damage Payout 04 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori A recent case underscores the critical importance of ensuring adequate insurance coverage for businesses. A cafe and catering business, forced to close after a storm, faced a significant reduction in its insurance claim due to underinsurance. - read more

Insurer Ordered to Pay Restaurant's Arson Claim Amid Non-Disclosure Dispute 04 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has significant implications for business insurance policies, particularly concerning the disclosure of directors' criminal histories. - read more

NSW Implements Stricter Penalties to Combat CTP Claims Farming 04 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori The New South Wales (NSW) government has taken decisive action to curb the practice of claims farming within the Compulsory Third Party (CTP) insurance scheme, introducing legislation that imposes significant penalties on such activities. - read more

NSW Strata Managers to Eliminate Insurance Commissions by 2026 04 Mar 2026: Paige Estritori In a significant move towards greater transparency, the Strata Community Association New South Wales (SCA NSW) has announced that, starting January 1, 2026, its members will phase out the acceptance of insurance commissions in their management contracts. This shift aims to replace traditional commission-based remuneration with a clear fee-for-service model, aligning with evolving industry standards and consumer expectations. - read more